Monday, May 19, 2008

[BurmaSolidarity] Myanmar cyclone death toll soars above 43,000

from: Ben Hur
date: Fri, May 16, 2008 at 2:50 AM
subject: [BurmaSolidarity] Myanmar cyclone death toll soars above 43,000 Re: [BurmaSolidarity] 16 May 2008 - Meeting regarding a team from India to Burma to help with relief efforts

Myanmar cyclone death toll soars above 43,000

May 15, 208- (23:30 India Stdrd Time) 1 hour, 30 minutes ago

YANGON, Myanmar - Myanmar's junta warned Thursday that legal action would be taken against people who trade or hoard international aid as the cyclone's death toll soared above 43,000.

It was the first acknowledgment by the military government, albeit indirectly, of problems with relief operations in the aftermath of Cyclone Nargis.

The warning came amid reports that foreign aid was being sold openly in markets, and that the military was pilfering and diverting aid for its own use.

The ruling junta has been blasted by aid agencies for refusing to allow most foreign experts into the hard-hit Irrawaddy delta and not responding adequately to what they say is a spiraling crisis.

Relief workers reported that some storm survivors were being given spoiled or poor-quality food rather than nutrition-rich biscuits sent by international donors, adding to fears that the ruling military junta in the Southeast Asian country could be misappropriating assistance.

New York-based Human Rights Watch said in a statement Wednesday that it had confirmed an Associated Press report that the military had seized high-energy biscuits that came from abroad, and distributed low-quality, locally produced biscuits to survivors.

Thursday's state radio announcement obliquely denied the military was misappropriating aid.

"The government has systematically accepted donations and has distributed the relief goods immediately and directly to the victims," it said. "Effective legal action will be taken against those who hoard, sell or buy, use or misuse the international or local donations or relief goods or cash to the cyclone victims."

Elisabeth Byrs, spokeswoman for the U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, said aid workers who visited all the major markets in Yangon found no evidence of hoarding or sale of relief goods.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies spokesman Matthew Cochrane said the organization also had not received any such reports.

The government said Thursday that the official death toll from the May 2-3 cyclone had climbed by almost 5,000 to 43,318. The number of missing has remained at 27,838 for at least two days.

But the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies estimated the death toll was between 68,833 and 127,990. The U.N. says more than 100,000 may have died.

The U.N. and the Red Cross say between 1.6 and 2.5 million people are in urgent need of food, water and shelter. Only 270,000 have been reached so far by the aid groups.

Tons of foreign aid including water, blankets, mosquito nets, tarpaulins, medicines and tents have been sent to Myanmar, but its delivery has been slowed down because of bottlenecks, poor infrastructure and bureaucratic tangles.

The junta insists on taking control of the distribution. It has allowed the U.N. and some other agencies to hand out the aid directly but prohibited their few foreign staff allowed into Myanmar from leaving Yangon, the country's main city.

Police have turned back foreigners from checkpoints at the city's exits.

"There is a visible fence around Yangon that we don't dare cross. A circle has been drawn around Yangon and expats are confined there," said Tim Costello of aid group World Vision.

He said the group has delivered aid to 100,000 people in spite of the "narrow parameters." But there are tens of thousands more who haven't received help because of heavy rain and lack of helicopters and expert staff.

"While you are getting aid through, it's like getting it through on a 3-inch pipe not 30-inch pipe," Costello said.

The regime insists it can handle the disaster on its own — a stance that appears to stem not from its abilities but its deep suspicion of most foreigners, who have frequently criticized its human rights abuses and crackdown on democracy activists.

In a clear sign that politics is playing a role, the junta granted approval to 160 relief workers from India, China, Bangladesh and Thailand, which have rarely criticized Myanmar's democracy record.

Pentagon spokesman Bryan Whitman said Thursday that so far the U.S. has done 13 airlifts. Reports from the ground indicate "that international relief supplies transported by the Burmese military have been arriving in disaster areas," he said.

"It's impossible for us to completely verify that all the relief supplies are getting to the affected areas but we are monitoring that through our contacts that are inside the country" — UN and aid private aid groups, he said. "And to the best of our ability, to date, we have not seen any U.S. assistance that has been diverted."

He said the Navy ships from the USS Essex expeditionary strike group were moved slightly after Wednesday's warning of another approaching storm, but they now remain some 30 nautical off Myanmar's coast, also waiting to help if asked.

Even Myanmar citizens are being restricted by the security forces, said Zaw Htin, a 21-year-old medical student who visited hard-hit Bogalay town on Wednesday.

"They (military) don't want us to stay and talk to people. They want us to leave the supplies with them for distribution. But how can I treat them if I can't talk to them? How do we administer medical care if we can't touch them, feel their pulse or give them advice?" she said.

"It was overwhelming even for us who have seen a lot of suffering and death," Zaw Htin said.

Britain's prime minister said Thursday that an emergency U.N. summit to coordinate efforts to rush aid to cyclone victims in Myanmar will be held in Asia.

Gordon Brown told a news conference the summit was being organized by the U.N. and Asian countries and would be held in the region. He said the meeting represented "great progress" but gave no details of when it would take place.

Also Thursday, the junta announced that voters had overwhelmingly backed a pro-military constitution in a referendum that was held one week after the cyclone.

Human rights organizations and dissident groups bitterly accused the junta of neglecting disaster victims in going ahead with the vote, and have criticized the proposed constitution as designed to perpetuate military rule.

State radio said the draft constitution was approved by 92.4 percent of the 22 million eligible voters. It put voter turnout Saturday at more than 99 percent of eligible voters in areas that went to the polls.

Voting was postponed until May 24 in the Irrawaddy delta and Yangon areas, which were worst hit by Cyclone Nargis. But state radio said the results of the late balloting could not mathematically reverse the constitution's approval.

"People are dying and they are talking about the referendum?" said Kyaw Muang, a small food store owner in Yangon. "They (the generals) don't even care about dying people, you think they care about democracy for living people?" he said.

"I don't care about the referendum. It doesn't mean anything," he said.

Human Rights Watch also slammed the timing of the constitution announcement and questioned the accuracy of the results.

David Mathieson, a spokesman in Bangkok, Thailand, said the junta hopes that by announcing the results now it would divert attention away from its handling of the disaster and its refusal to cooperate with the international community.

"It seems strategically timed because you would have thought with how busy they were in cleaning up the cyclone that they never would have had time to count this properly," he said.

U.N. says up to 2.5 million affected in Myanmar cyclone

By Aung Hla Tun 1 hour, 15 minutes ago

YANGON (Reuters) - The United Nations said on Wednesday up to 2.5 million people might have been affected by the Myanmar cyclone and proposed a high-level donors conference as the Myanmar junta again limited foreign aid.

The European Union's top aid official said the military government's restrictions on foreign aid workers and equipment were increasing the risk of starvation and disease.

U.N. humanitarian affairs chief John Holmes told reporters between 1.6 and 2.5 million people were "severely affected" by Cyclone Nargis and urgently needed aid, up from a previous estimate of at least 1.5 million.

Thai Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej met Myanmar Prime Minister Thein Sein in Yangon and urged him to ease visa rules for relief workers. He said he was told Myanmar could "tackle the problem by themselves."

Myanmar state television raised its official toll to 38,491 dead, 1,403 injured and 27,838 missing.

The International Federation of the Red Cross estimated on the basis of reports from 22 organizations working in Myanmar that between 68,833 and 127,990 people had died.

In New York, U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, who has repeatedly expressed frustration over the slow response of Myanmar's reclusive leaders, proposed holding a "high-level pledging conference" to deal with the crisis.

Ban spoke to reporters after meeting with representatives of Myanmar and countries from Asia, Europe and America.

Britain's U.N. ambassador, John Sawers, however, indicated that the high-level conference would be more than a donors' meeting, calling it a "major international meeting" in line with Prime Minister Gordon Brown's calls for a U.N. summit on coordinating aid efforts in Myanmar.

Ban also proposed appointing a joint coordinator from the U.N and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations to oversee aid delivery and said he would soon send Holmes to Myanmar.

Myanmar's U.N. ambassador, Kyaw Tint Swe, said he was pleased that participants had agreed the crisis should not be politicized but must remain a humanitarian issue.

However, Ban, Sawers and U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad all said failure to properly handle the crisis would inevitably politicize it.

"The way it will get politicized is if ... assistance is not allowed to arrive in a timely manner to save lives, and no time should be lost," Khalilzad said. "The Myanmar government has a responsibility to ensure lives are saved, not lost."


Nearly two weeks after the deadly cyclone swept through the heavily populated Irrawaddy delta, foreign aid was still a trickle.

Myanmar, formerly called Burma, was once the world's biggest rice exporting country, but more than 40 years of military rule have left it impoverished. The military junta has repeatedly crushed pro-democracy movements and tightly restricts visits by foreigners.

Samak told reporters in Bangkok that Myanmar's leaders had insisted that teams of foreign experts, who have been refused entry, were not needed.

"They are confident of dealing with the problem by themselves. There are no outbreaks of diseases, no starvation, no famine. They don't need experts, but are willing to get aid supplies from every country," Samak said.

Louis Michel, the top European Union aid official, disagreed. "There is a risk of water pollution. There is a risk of starvation because the storages of rice have been destroyed," he told reporters in Bangkok.

"We want to convince the authorities of our good faith. We are there for humanitarian reasons," he said. He dismissed suggestions from some European countries that they should bring in aid without awaiting permission from the authorities.

Adm. Timothy Keating, the commander of U.S. forces in the Pacific, also rejected that idea.

He said U.S. emergency aid flights would continue for the time being, despite Myanmar refusing permission for U.S. officials to monitor, or help with, distribution.

A senior U.S. military official in Washington said there were signs aid was stacking up at Yangon airport and said Washington wants to fly choppers to the areas hit worst.

The official said there were reports that some 230 camps had been set up to house more than 230,000 displaced people. "They're springing up all over the place," he said. "The problem they have is a lack of water and sanitary facilities."

Officials said despite reports that some supplies were being stolen or diverted by the army, the humanitarian needs were so great that they would keep making deliveries -- while continuing to urge that U.S. aid workers be granted visas.

World Food Program chief Josette Sheeran said in Washington her organization had so far reached 28,000 people.

"A critical issue now is access," she said. "Our flights are allowed to bring in some supplies, but far from enough - a massive effort is needed to save lives..." she told a U.S. Senate hearing.

Holmes also warned that epidemics of diseases like cholera, malaria and measles "can break out at any time now."

One group of Christian doctors has been treating children in churches, operating below the government's radar. "We have to try to do something," said one of the doctors, giving children diarrhea medicine in a church north of Yangon.

More heavy rain and winds were forecast in the delta as a tropical depression moved in, but the U.N. weather agency discounted fears a new cyclone was forming.

In a gesture to critics, Myanmar's rulers invited 160 personnel from Bangladesh, China, India and Thailand to assist in the relief, but experts said that was a fraction of the number needed.

(Additional reporting by Darren Schuettler, Nopporn Wong-Anan, Carmel Crimmins amd Pracha Hariraksapitak in Bangkok; Louis Charbonneau at the United Nations; Susan Cornwell and Missy Ryan in Washington)

(Writing by Louis Charbonneau and Jerry Norton; Editing by Alan Elsner)

(For more stories on Myanmar cyclone follow the link to Reuters AlertNet

No comments: